For more than three decades, the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City has hosted the annual Jackson Hole Economic Policy Symposium, where dozens of central bankers, policymakers, academics and economists gather.
Jackson Hole is a valley located between the Gros Ventre and Teton mountain ranges in the US state of Wyoming, near the border with Idaho. Those lucky enough to hike there encounter elks, bison, golden hawks and bears.
At last week’s symposium, bears and hawks were center stage...
Many economists were expecting a non-event. The latest inflation figures suggested a rather balanced message from Fed Chairman Jay Powell. He was expected to be an "iron fist in a velvet glove", i.e. firm on the continuation of monetary tightening but also showing some signs that the Fed is ready to slow down the rate hikes if the economic data (inflation as well as growth) justify it.
However, Jay Powell's very short speech - 10 minutes as opposed to the usual half hour - was interpreted as a hawkish one, i.e. resolutely turned towards a longer and more important monetary tightening than the market had hoped for.
Quoting both former central bankers Paul Volcker and Alan Greenspan, Jerome Powell presented his speech in the form of 3 distinct lessons:
Jay Powell added that continued tight monetary policy is likely to be necessary for some time and that history "warns against premature easing" of monetary policy.
In conclusion, Mr Powell tried to convince investors that the rate cuts in 2023 that are currently expected by the market are too optimistic. As the chart below shows, the dichotomy between the Fed's projections and those of the market was striking before Jackson Hole. For its part, the Fed intends to raise rates for a relatively long period of time with no intention of lowering them anytime soon. However, the markets were expecting very short-term rate hikes that will give way to rate cuts as early as 2023.
US interest rates expected by the market and projected by the Fed BEFORE Jackson Hole
Source: Bloomberg
It would seem that Mr Powell does not see it that way and took advantage of the Symposium to clarify his message...
The market adjustment was almost instantaneous. On Friday, just after Mr Powell's speech, the yield curve indicated that investors now expect the Fed to raise interest rates to 3.8% by February 2023, compared to expectations of 3.3% at the beginning of the month. In terms of sequencing, markets now assign a high probability to the following scenario:
The first rate cut would not occur until late 2023 or early 2024.
Source: Charlie Bilello
The focus on inflation - compared to the Fed's other priority, the labour market - can be seen in the table below which counts the words used in the Chairman's speech. In the recent past, employment was the focus before the pandemic and "transitory inflation" (!) took over. This year it was indeed the phrase "high inflation" that was most used in his speech, while employment was not mentioned once.
Number of times Mr Powell quoted the following words in his Jackson Hole speech in 2020, 2021 and 2022
Source: Bloomberg
The priority given to the fight against inflation at the expense of growth was hammered home during Powell's speech. Indeed, the Fed Chairman also issued a clear warning to the American public: prepare for hard times. For Mr Powell, reducing inflationary pressures will likely require a prolonged period of below-trend growth with a deteriorating labour market. Even though much of the inflation is supply-side, it is the Fed's job to bring down demand to restore price balance, he said.
But if higher interest rates, slower growth and higher unemployment bring inflation down, households and businesses should be prepared to pay the price, Powell warned.
To avoid an overly negative reaction from the markets, Mr Powell nevertheless addressed a message to the doves: "Later, when the stance of monetary policy tightens further, it will probably become appropriate to slow the pace of rate hikes". A "consolation prize" that proved insufficient...
Tight monetary policy at the expense of growth - a formula that investors are not happy with. Since the publication of July's inflation figures, markets had begun to anticipate the Fed's famous "pivot", i.e. a forthcoming inflexion in monetary policy, which had led to a rally in risky assets. Jackson Hole dashed these hopes and the impact on the markets was immediate - the bears are back!
US stocks fell sharply after Powell's speech. The S&P 500 index fell 3.4%, while the Nasdaq Composite, dominated by technology stocks that are more sensitive to interest rate expectations, lost 3.9%. This was the biggest daily decline for both indices since mid-June.
US stocks fell sharply after Powell's speech
Source: FT
Friday's drop in US stocks was particularly broad-based, with about 99% of S&P 500 companies down on the day. Investors believe that higher interest rates and a continued economic slowdown will weigh on corporate earnings later this year.
Surprisingly, the bond market showed little reaction to Mr Powell's speech. Long-dated bond yields and two-year yields remained stable.
Why did stocks and bonds react so differently? One possible interpretation is that the bond market seems to expect that the Fed's restrictive policy will weigh on growth and inflation leading to aggressive interest rate cuts later on.
The equity market is not convinced by these assumptions and does not seem to give much credibility to Mr Powell who has tightened too much in 2018, stimulated too much in 2021, and is now trying to emulate Paul Volcker at a time when core PCE inflation (released last week) is at its lowest level (4.6%) since October.
We continue to believe that US monetary policy will remain tight for some time to come. Admittedly, the pace of rate hikes may slow down, but this does not mean that the Fed is about to "pivot" because 1) real rates remain very negative (see chart below); 2) economic data for July do not point to an eminent economic recession; 3) financial conditions (equity markets, credit spreads, etc.) have eased throughout the summer. In other words, the Fed has a free hand to make the necessary rate hikes.
Real Fed Funds Rate in the US
Source: Pantera
We should also bear in mind that the pace of QT will be doubled from September onwards (up to $95bn per month of Fed balance sheet reduction).
The current monetary policy conditions are therefore not favourable to risky assets, even though earnings growth expectations are being revised downwards and the price/earnings multiple of the S&P 500 cannot be seen as cheap (18x earnings expectations for the next 12 months). We reiterate our cautious message on equities.
